As the summer crowds fade and the crisp air of autumn sets in, Martha’s Vineyard transforms into a tranquil escape, offering locals and visitors a chance to enjoy some of the island’s most exclusive beaches. With restrictions easing after Labor Day, September is the perfect time to experience the serene beauty of private beaches that are usually off-limits during the bustling summer months. 

Known for its diverse coastline, Martha’s Vineyard offers everything from calm, shallow waters to rolling surf along the south shore. This post-summer window is an ideal opportunity for beach lovers seeking a quieter, more intimate connection with the island’s stunning landscapes. Below, we explore a few of the most sought-after private beaches that become more accessible as fall approaches. You can quickly see a full list of island beaches here. 

Lambert’s Cove Beach

Lambert’s Cove Beach, tucked away in West Tisbury on the north shore of the island, is a true gem. During the summer, this beach is restricted to West Tisbury residents and their guests, but come mid-September, it opens up to the public, allowing everyone to enjoy its pristine sands. A short drive from Vineyard Haven, Lambert’s Cove offers breathtaking views of Vineyard Sound, with the Elizabeth Islands visible in the distance.

One of the key features of Lambert’s Cove Beach is its luxurious, soft white sand – arguably the finest on the island. The calm, warm waters make it perfect for swimmers, and the beach’s serene atmosphere is enhanced by its spectacular sunsets, which often rival those seen at Menemsha Beach. Whether you visit for a peaceful morning walk or a sunset picnic, Lambert’s Cove is an idyllic spot to soak in the beauty of Martha’s Vineyard in the fall.

Lucy Vincent Beach

Located off South Road in Chilmark, Lucy Vincent Beach is another hidden treasure that becomes accessible to the public after Labor Day. This beach is famed for its dramatic rock formations and striking cliffs, offering one of the most unique landscapes on the island. While Chilmark residents and renters have exclusive access during the summer, the relaxed fall atmosphere makes it a perfect destination for a quieter, scenic beach day.

Lucy Vincent’s sandy shore and active surf attract photographers and beachgoers alike, with many flocking here for the stunning sunrises and waves. Known for its occasional nude sunbathers, the beach also offers a laid-back vibe that fits perfectly with the Vineyard’s free spirit. Fall mornings here are particularly beautiful, with the sun rising over the cliffs and casting a golden glow on the landscape.

Squibnocket Beach

For those who love surfing or simply enjoy watching the waves, Squibnocket Beach, or “Squibby” as the locals call it, is a must-visit in September. Located on the southern coast of Chilmark, Squibnocket is known for its strong surf and rocky shoreline, offering a rugged, natural beauty. After being reserved for Chilmark residents in the summer, the beach opens to the public in the fall, making it a prime spot for surfers and adventurers looking to enjoy the crashing waves.

A recent renovation project added a new parking lot and bridge, making the beach even more accessible. Whether you’re here to surf or take in the striking views, Squibnocket Beach in the fall provides a secluded and peaceful setting to unwind.

Philbin Beach

Located in Aquinnah, Philbin Beach is another exclusive spot that opens up after the summer crowds leave. Known for its heavy surf, Philbin is a favorite among surfers and those seeking a more rugged beach experience. The wide, expansive beach offers breathtaking views of the Atlantic, and in the fall, the cooler temperatures make it perfect for long walks along the shoreline. Access via Moshup Trail makes Philbin a bit more off-the-beaten-path, adding to its allure.

Enjoying Martha’s Vineyard Beaches Responsibly

As you explore these serene, private beaches in September, keep in mind that all Martha’s Vineyard beaches follow a strict “Carry In, Carry Out” policy. Be sure to bring along everything you need and take your trash with you to preserve the island’s natural beauty.

From Lambert’s Cove’s calm waters to Squibnocket’s roaring surf, Martha’s Vineyard offers a variety of beach experiences, each with its own charm. Whether you're a swimmer, surfer, or simply seeking a peaceful day by the shore, fall is the best time to rediscover the island’s most exclusive beaches without the summer crowds.

For a complete guide to Martha’s Vineyard beaches, including maps and seasonal access details, visit MVY.com.